The episode beings in 2005 as he enters a child's house and is approached by "To Catch A Predator" host, Chris Hansen. The Booty Warrior reveals that he didn't want sex with a child but Chris Hansen himself and tells him his well known phrase "I like ya, and I want'cha. Now we can do this the easy way or we can do this the hard way, the choice is yours". Hansen tells him that dosen't want anything to do with that and turns around shouting "Cut" and the booty warrior then becomes angry and tackles Hansen, easily pinning him to the counter raping him but is arrested afterwards.
The episode then fast forwards 5 years in 2010 when Tom Dubois is hoping to help Huey and Riley and other young students from going to prison and being violated by putting them in the "Scared Stiff Program"; a program where troubled juveniles go to the prison and interact with several of the prisoners learning how life in prison will affect them in hopes of "scaring them straight". One of the prisoners uses Tom as an example of what the prison system does to people. He forces Tom to strip almost completely naked and the Booty Warrior seen earlier in the episode sees that Tom had a sharpened toothbrush and places it in his pocket. He then takes his turn and explains how important Booty is in prison and tells Tom the same phrase he told Chris Hansen. Tom, terrified by the man is unable to answer. The booty warrior takes this as Tom is choosing the hard way and holds him at knifepoint using the sharpened toothbrush. Muliple guards come in and Tom uses a self defense technique he learned in therapy to free himself and immediately runs off to look for saftey. As a result, a prison riot starts with hundreds of prisoners easily taking down and possibly raping many of the guards.
The Booty Warrior complains that Tom ran away and has a brief argument with the prisoners. The group, held hostage, feigns about not knowing a successful escape plan. Annoyed, the booty warrior attempts to find Tom so he can rape him. Tom realizes that when he helped Uncle ruckus and the white children escape from the prisoners holding them hostages that they had left Huey and Riley behind. Tom, feeling responsible for letting the prisoners take the childern hostage decides to go back to save Huey and Riley with Uncle Ruckus telling Tom to look out for the peanut jelly prisoner saying he has peanut allergies. After seeing a group of prisoners, Tom rushes to the showers. Before he can see him, the booty warrior is then heard saying "Tom come out to play".
The Booty Warrior, completely naked except for his green hat, runs through the steam of the shower room and starts throwing mulitiple bars of soap at Tom. The two begin to fight and Tom does suprisingly well but the booty warrior gains the upperhand due to his great resilience and strength. He starts walking towards Tom confidently but humorously slips on a bar of soap hitting the back of his head. Tom grabs the soap that the Booty Warrior slipped on, Tom screaming "You can't have it!" and throws it at the booty warrior defeating him and consequently fully conquers his fear of prison rape.
After this the prisoners notice that Uncle Ruckus and the white childern are gone and decide that they won't have any stastitic leverage with only two childern and give up. One of the prisoners tells Huey that after spending so much time in prison he deeply regrets his actions that put him in jail and always wishes that things could have been different and the only thing he can do is to rape other inmates for the rest of his life. Tom then rushes in but sees the prisoners gone and asks if they're okay which Huey replies they are fine and asks Tom if he's doing alright and replies yes, showing for the first time that he's okay and that he can now live his life more happier and free now that he had beaten his lifelong fear that heavily influenced his life.